Yoder Laser Concrete
Home » Parking Lots and Paving » Concrete vs Asphalt Parking Lots: Cost, Life and Upkeep

Concrete vs Asphalt Parking Lots: Cost, Life and Upkeep

Finished commercial concrete parking lot with painted striping at an Ohio retail plaza

Asphalt usually costs less to install, and concrete usually costs less to own. A concrete parking lot lasts longer, needs less routine maintenance and handles heavy trucks and summer heat without rutting. Asphalt goes down faster and cheaper, is easier to patch, but needs sealcoating and resurfacing on a regular cycle. For many commercial sites the best answer is both: asphalt where cars park, and concrete where trucks turn, stop and load.

Upfront cost

Asphalt is normally the cheaper paving to install, though the gap moves with oil prices, cement prices and the design thickness. Our guide to what a yard of concrete costs in Ohio has current ready-mix prices. When you compare bids, compare the full section: subgrade preparation, base thickness, pavement thickness and drainage. A cheap number with a thin base is not a fair comparison with a properly designed concrete section.

Lifespan

A well-built concrete parking lot commonly lasts 25 to 30 years or more. Asphalt lots usually need a new surface sooner, often after 15 to 20 years, even with good maintenance. Climate, traffic and drainage move both numbers. Our post on how long a concrete parking lot lasts covers what shortens or extends it.

Maintenance

  • Asphalt needs sealcoating every few years, crack filling, and eventually milling and an overlay. Each of those closes part of the lot.
  • Concrete needs its joints kept sealed, cracks sealed when they appear, and occasional cleaning. Some owners also apply a penetrating sealer; see how often to seal a concrete parking lot.

Heavy trucks and heat

This is where concrete pulls ahead. Asphalt softens in hot weather and deforms under heavy, slow or parked loads, which is why truck turnarounds, dock aprons and dumpster pads rut and shove on asphalt lots. Concrete is rigid and spreads the load over a wider area of the base, so it holds its shape where trailers stand on their landing gear and where trucks turn sharply.

Drainage and appearance

Concrete holds the slopes it was built to, so water keeps draining to the inlets instead of ponding in ruts. Its lighter color also reflects more light at night and stays cooler in summer.

Ohio winters

Freeze-thaw cycles and deicing salt are hard on any pavement. Exterior concrete in Ohio should be air entrained, a mix design that puts tiny air bubbles in the paste so freezing water has somewhere to go. Avoid deicing salt on new concrete in its first winter, and never use deicers based on ammonium nitrate or ammonium sulfate, which attack concrete. Asphalt does not scale, but frost and water get into its cracks and turn them into potholes.

Repairs

Asphalt is easier to patch in small areas. Concrete is repaired panel by panel along its joints, which takes longer per repair but happens far less often.

Which should you choose?

Installed costHigherLower
Typical life25 to 30+ years15 to 20 years before resurfacing
Routine upkeepJoint and crack sealingSealcoating, crack filling, overlays
Heavy trucks and heatHolds shapeCan rut and shove
Small repairsPanel replacementEasy patching

If the lot carries mostly cars and the budget is tight now, asphalt can make sense. If it carries trucks, forklifts or dumpsters, or the owner plans to keep the property for decades, concrete pays back. Combining the two puts each material where it performs best.

Planning a lot or truck court?

We build concrete parking lots, truck courts and dock aprons for commercial and industrial sites across Ohio, Indiana, Michigan, West Virginia and Pennsylvania. Our guide to how thick a concrete parking lot should be covers the design, or send your site plan for a reply within 24 hours. The American Concrete Pavement Association has more on concrete pavement design and life-cycle cost.

Daniel Yoder, owner of Yoder Laser Concrete, on a commercial jobsite

About Daniel Yoder

Daniel Yoder is the owner of Yoder Laser Concrete, a commercial concrete contractor based in Millersburg, Ohio. View Daniel’s profile and guides

Keep Reading

More Commercial Concrete Guides